Computer Copier
Windows 10 & 11 Buy license · $29.95
Buying guide

PC Transfer Software vs Copying Files Yourself vs Cloud: Which Is Best?

Copying files by hand, using OneDrive or using PC transfer software: what each misses, how long each takes, and which suits your move.

Updated 4 minute read The Computer Copier team

Copying files manually works well when one person is moving a few folders and knows exactly where everything is. Cloud storage such as OneDrive is convenient for the folders it covers but is limited by your storage plan and internet speed. PC transfer software is worth it when there are several user accounts, lots of data, email files, bookmarks or settings to move, or when you want a record that every file arrived.

The real difference is not speed so much as what gets left behind. Here is what each method covers, what it misses, and how to choose.

Copying files manually vs PC transfer software vs cloud at a glance

Copy by handCloud (OneDrive)Transfer software
CostFree if you have a driveFree up to your plan's storageUsually a paid license
What limits the timeDrive or network speed, plus your own timeYour internet upload and download speedDrive or network speed
Every user accountOnly if you copy each oneEach person signs in separatelyUsually, if supported
Moved folders and other drivesOnly if you find themOnly folders inside OneDriveDepends on the product
Email data and bookmarksManual export and importNoOften
Wi-Fi, printers, mapped drivesRe-enter by handNoOften, selectable
Proof of what movedNoNoA report, in good products

How to copy files to a new PC by hand

For a single user with mostly documents and photos, the manual method is perfectly sound:

  1. Plug an external drive into the old PC. Check it is formatted as NTFS or exFAT, not FAT32, if you have any files over 4 GB.
  2. Open C:\Users\Sarah and copy Documents, Pictures, Music, Videos, Desktop and Downloads to the drive.
  3. Check This PC for other drives and copy any folders you use from them.
  4. Plug the drive into the new PC and copy each folder into the matching folder there.
  5. Compare the size of each folder on both PCs (right-click, Properties) before you wipe anything.

For large folders, robocopy in Command Prompt is more dependable than drag and drop because it retries failed files and can be run again to pick up only what changed. For example, robocopy C:\Users\Sarah\Documents E:\Sarah\Documents /E /R:1 /W:1 copies Documents and all its subfolders to drive E:. Our guide to transferring files with an external hard drive covers this route step by step.

What copying by hand usually misses

The manual method only copies what you think to copy. The things people most often discover missing later are:

  • Other users' files. A partner's or child's account under C:\Users.
  • Moved folders. Documents or Desktop relocated to D: or into OneDrive, so the default folder looks nearly empty.
  • Email. Outlook (classic) PST files in Documents\Outlook Files need importing with File > Open & Export; Thunderbird mail lives in a hidden profile under AppData\Roaming\Thunderbird\Profiles.
  • Bookmarks. Each browser keeps them in a hidden profile folder and needs its own export and import.
  • Settings. Saved Wi-Fi passwords, network printers, mapped drives, regional formats and wallpaper all have to be set up again.

None of this is hard on its own, but it adds up, and nothing tells you when you have missed something. Our list of what to transfer to a new computer is a useful checklist if you go the manual way.

Is cloud storage a good way to move to a new PC?

If your Desktop, Documents and Pictures are already backed up to OneDrive, the new PC gets them as soon as you sign in, which is genuinely easy. With Files On-Demand, files can appear straight away and download only when opened.

The catch is everything outside those folders, and the size of the job. Moving a large photo or video library through the cloud means uploading it all from the old PC and downloading it again on the new one, and home internet upload speeds are often much slower than a local network or USB drive. You also need enough storage on your plan to hold it all. Windows Backup can add settings and an app list, but it still works one Microsoft account at a time.

Cloud and local transfer are not either/or. Many people let OneDrive handle the folders it already syncs and move everything else directly.

How long does each method take?

It depends almost entirely on how much data you have and the connection. A local transfer over an Ethernet cable or to a fast USB drive is usually limited by the drives themselves. A cloud move is usually limited by your internet upload speed, which can turn a large library into a multi-day job. Copying by hand also costs your own time: finding folders, exporting from programs and re-entering settings, which is often the longest part.

When transfer software is worth it

  • More than one person used the old PC.
  • You have a lot of data, or files spread across drives.
  • You use desktop email, or have years of bookmarks.
  • You want Wi-Fi networks, printers and mapped drives set up without re-entering them.
  • You are doing it for someone else and need to show what was moved.

Doing it with Computer Copier

Computer Copier covers the gaps in the manual method. It finds Documents, Pictures, Music, Videos, Desktop and Downloads for every user on the old PC, including folders moved to another drive or into OneDrive, and lists other folders and drives for you to tick. It brings browser bookmarks, Outlook PST files and Thunderbird profiles, and lets you choose settings such as Wi-Fi networks with their passwords, network printers and mapped drives.

The transfer runs directly between the PCs over your network, or through a USB drive, with nothing uploaded to the cloud, and the OneDrive folder is optional because OneDrive syncs by itself. Every file is checked against the original, and the transfer report shows everything copied and anything that could not be, with the reason.

Frequently asked questions

Is it OK to copy my files to a new PC by hand?

Yes, for a single user with a few folders. It is easy to miss hidden data such as email files, bookmarks and other users' folders.

Is cloud storage a good way to move to a new PC?

It is convenient for the folders it covers, but uploading and downloading lots of data is slow and can need a paid plan.

When is transfer software worth it?

When there are several users, lots of data, email files or settings to move, or you want proof that every file arrived.

Get three guides like this every month, plus software update notices.Subscribe →